Hello dolls! I went thrifting last weekend and it was one of those sessions where everything just clicked. You know those days — when the racks are full and the lighting is actually decent and you pull out piece after piece and think yes, yes, absolutely yes. I left with eight things and spent less than thirty dollars on all of them, and I have been putting outfits together in my head ever since.
I want to walk you through everything I found, what I paid for each piece, and exactly how I’m planning to style it — because I think haul posts are only actually useful when they include the styling part. Anyone can show you a pile of clothes from a thrift store. The interesting question is how those specific pieces are going to live in a real wardrobe, what they’re going to be paired with, and why they were worth buying in the first place. That’s what I want to give you today.
I’ll also talk at the end about the things I picked up and put back down and why, because I think the decision not to buy something is just as interesting and instructive as the decision to buy it, and it’s something haul posts almost never cover.
The Store and the Approach
I went to the Value Village near my neighbourhood, which is one of my regular stops and one I’ve had consistent luck at over the years. It’s a larger store than most thrift shops in the city which means the volume of inventory is high enough that something interesting surfaces regularly, and it restocks several times a week so going back every few days rather than once a month genuinely pays off in terms of what you find.
My approach when I walk into a thrift store is deliberate rather than random. I don’t just browse the whole store and see what catches my eye — I have a mental list of what I’m looking for going in, which keeps me from buying things impulsively that I don’t actually need and helps me move through the racks more efficiently. This time my list was: something in the camel or rust family to add warmth to my palette, a blazer if the right one appeared, anything interesting in knitwear, and boots if anything showed up in my size. Everything else was potential but not a priority.
I spent about an hour and a half in the store. Here is everything I brought home.
Find One: The Rust Corduroy Blazer — $6
I almost walked past this one because it was hanging with the men’s jackets rather than the women’s section, which is where a lot of the best blazer finds hide. It’s a slightly oversized single-breasted blazer in a warm rust-orange corduroy with wide wale texture — the kind of corduroy that has those broad, soft ridges rather than the fine-line variety. The colour is exactly what I was looking for: a deep, warm rust that photographs beautifully in fall light and works as the earthy accent piece I wanted to add to a mostly black and neutral wardrobe.
The fit is slightly oversized on me, which is intentional and correct for this kind of piece. The shoulders sit at the very edge of my actual shoulder, the sleeves are a touch long and I’ve already rolled them to just below the elbow, and the body falls to just above the hip in that relaxed, slouchy way that makes a blazer look fashion-forward rather than stuffy. The lining is intact, all the buttons are present and original, and the corduroy itself has very minimal wear.
How I’m styling it: the combination I’ve already worn twice this week is the rust blazer over a fitted black ribbed turtleneck, straight-leg black jeans, and black ankle boots. The rust against all the black is exactly the warm accent I was after — it’s a pop of colour that feels intentional and autumnal without being loud. I’ve also worn it over a cream silk-look camisole with wide-leg camel trousers and white sneakers for a more relaxed daytime look, where the rust, cream, and camel all sit in the same warm neutral family and the blazer ties the colour story together. On the weekend I threw it over a simple grey crewneck and dark jeans as a casual layer and that was genuinely great too. A six dollar blazer that goes with three different outfit formulas in the first week is a very good purchase.
Find Two: The Cream Chunky Knit Turtleneck — $4
This was hanging on the knitwear rack and I almost didn’t look at it because the hanger photograph always undersells a chunky knit — they collapse on a hanger in a way that makes them look shapeless and sad. But I pulled it out and felt the weight of it and knew immediately it was worth trying. It’s a substantial cream cable-knit turtleneck in a size large, which gives it an oversized fit that falls to just below the hip. The fabric is a wool blend — I checked the label — which means it’s genuinely warm rather than just decorative knitwear, and the cable pattern is a classic traditional design that will never look dated.
There were three very small areas of light pilling on the front that I dealt with in about five minutes with my fabric shaver before wearing it. After that the sweater looked essentially new. This is the transformation that I talk about every time I discuss thrift store knitwear — a piece that looked slightly tired in the store looks completely fresh after ten minutes of care at home.
How I’m styling it: this sweater is going to carry me through the rest of fall and all of winter and I am not exaggerating. The cream colour works with everything in my wardrobe — black, camel, rust, grey, dark denim. The cable-knit texture adds visual interest to even the simplest outfit. I’ve worn it already over black straight-leg jeans and ankle boots, which is the simplest possible formula and looks beautiful because the cream and black contrast is inherently strong. I’m planning to wear it as the under-layer in a midi-dress-over-turtleneck combination, to layer under my camel coat as the visible knit layer when the coat is open, and to try the shirt-collar-out combination where a button-up collar and cuffs peek out from underneath. Four dollars for a piece I’m going to wear this heavily is genuinely one of the best value purchases of the season.
Find Three: The Wide-Leg Dark Plaid Trousers — $7
These were a slightly unexpected find — I wasn’t specifically looking for trousers but these jumped off the rack the moment I saw them. They’re wide-leg, high-waisted trousers in a dark plaid — navy, black, and a thin rust stripe — in a heavy woven fabric that has real weight and drape. The waist is a perfect fit and the wide leg falls cleanly from the hip to the ankle without pulling or bunching. The plaid is subtle enough that it reads as a textured neutral from a distance but interesting up close.
Wide-leg trousers in a good fabric are one of those garments that make everything you pair them with look more intentional and elevated. There is something inherently fashion-forward about a really good wide leg — it’s a silhouette that requires confidence to wear and that confidence reads in photos and in person as someone who knows what they’re doing.
How I’m styling them: the rust blazer and the plaid trousers share that thin rust stripe in the plaid, which makes them a combination I’ve been excited about since I got them both home. Rust blazer, cream or black fitted top underneath, the plaid wide-legs, and either loafers or pointed-toe flats — this is an outfit that photographs like it came from a fashion editorial and cost me thirteen dollars total between the two pieces. I’m also wearing the trousers with the cream chunky turtleneck tucked in slightly at the front, which gives the heavy knit something structured to sit against and makes the whole thing feel very pulled-together. And for evenings, a fitted black bodysuit tucked into the plaid trousers with black pointed-toe heels is an outfit I’ve already planned out in my head for three different occasions.
Find Four: The Black Slip Dress — $5
There was never a question about whether I was buying this. A black satin-look slip dress in excellent condition for five dollars is not a decision — it’s a reflex. I have written about the slip dress as a year-round layering piece multiple times on this blog and I will continue to make that case every chance I get because it is correct. This particular one hits at midi length, has adjustable spaghetti straps, a slight bias cut that gives it movement, and a deep V neckline that means it works under things rather than being blocked by collar lines.
The fabric is polyester satin rather than real silk, which is completely fine for a thrift store find at this price — polyester satin has almost the same visual effect as silk satin at a fraction of the cost and the care requirements, and this particular example has a quality of drape and sheen that reads as quite luxurious in photos.
How I’m styling it: I’ve already worn it over a fitted black long-sleeve turtleneck with chunky black boots for a fully fall-appropriate outfit where the slip dress becomes the middle layer rather than the outermost one. I have plans to wear it under the rust blazer with straight-leg jeans peeking out below, which gives the outfit a layered complexity that looks deliberate and interesting. And on warmer days in early winter I’ll wear it on its own with a leather jacket and heeled boots for evenings out, which is the most classic version of the slip dress outfit and one that I find consistently rewarding to wear.
Find Five: The Camel Leather Belt — $2
Two dollars. For a genuine leather belt in camel with a simple gold buckle in perfect condition. I picked this up almost as an afterthought near the accessories bins and I have not stopped wearing it since. A camel leather belt is one of those small accessories that does enormous styling work — it defines a waist over any layer, it adds a warm accent to a neutral outfit, and it costs almost nothing secondhand because belts are easy to overlook in the accessories section where more dramatic pieces attract attention first.
How I’m styling it: over the cream chunky turtleneck on its own for a slightly seventies, belted-sweater look. Over the rust blazer when I wear it as a more fitted layer rather than an open overshirt. Over the plaid trousers with a tucked-in top to define the high waist even further. A camel belt at the natural waist appears in approximately half the outfits I put together and will continue to appear through the rest of the season without question.
Find Six: The Vintage Denim Jacket — $4
This one required a little faith. It was in the men’s section, it was faded to that specific shade of pale blue that only comes from actual decades of washing, it had slightly frayed cuffs and a stress mark near one pocket that looks exactly like denim is supposed to look when it’s been genuinely lived in rather than artificially distressed in a factory. It is a size large and it fits me with the slightly boxy, not-quite-mine energy that the best denim jackets have — like you borrowed it from someone who is slightly larger than you and decided to keep it.
Vintage denim jackets made before the nineties have a weight and a construction that current denim jackets at any price point rarely match. The denim is thicker, the stitching is more substantial, and the overall structure holds its shape in a way that thinner modern denim doesn’t. This one is old — the label style puts it somewhere in the mid-eighties — and it is in the kind of condition that only old denim in good condition achieves: faded and worn but entirely structurally intact.
How I’m styling it: over the black slip dress with black boots for that grunge-feminine contrast I wrote about in my hard-meets-soft post. Over a cream or white fitted tee with the plaid wide-leg trousers for a casual daytime outfit that takes about three minutes to put together and looks considerably more considered than that. And as a middle layer under the camel coat on transitional days when I want the visible layer under the coat to have some texture and personality of its own.
Find Seven: The Burgundy Midi Skirt — $3
A deep burgundy midi skirt in a heavy woven fabric — not jersey, not knit, a proper woven with structure and weight that holds the A-line shape without clinging. The colour is that specific deep wine-burgundy that is one of the quintessential fall shades and that I never seem to have enough of in my wardrobe. Three dollars. I am still slightly amazed.
The skirt has a side zip and a proper lining, both of which are signs of better construction than a lot of fast-fashion skirts — a lining keeps a midi skirt from becoming transparent in certain lights and from clinging to tights, and a side zip sits flatter than a back zip when tucked in. These are the details that tell you something about the quality of the original garment even without knowing the brand.
How I’m styling it: the cream chunky turtleneck tucked in at the front with the burgundy midi skirt and black over-the-knee boots is one of the most beautiful fall outfit formulas I know, and this combination of pieces executes it perfectly. The cream against the deep burgundy, the cable-knit texture against the smooth woven skirt fabric, the over-the-knee boots creating a continuous line from floor to knee — this is an outfit that looks like it costs much more than it does. I’m also wearing it with a fitted black turtleneck and ankle boots for a simpler version of the same formula, and with the rust blazer over a black top for an outfit where the rust and the burgundy share enough warmth to work as an intentional colour pairing.
Find Eight: The Brown Leather Crossbody Bag — $4
I almost never buy bags at thrift stores because the selection tends to be unpredictable and the condition can be hard to assess quickly, but this one was too good to pass up. A small structured crossbody in genuine leather — I checked by bending it and feeling the texture — in a warm cognac brown with a simple gold chain strap and a magnetic snap closure. The leather has a beautiful patina that only genuine leather develops with age: slightly uneven in tone, warm and rich rather than flat and uniform. The interior is clean. The hardware is intact. The strap is in perfect condition.
Brown leather accessories are one of those things I consistently underestimate and then reach for constantly when I have them. They warm up any outfit in a way that black leather doesn’t — there’s a different quality to the warmth a brown bag or belt adds versus the sharpness of black. Against the rust blazer, the camel coat, the cream turtleneck, the cognac brown of this bag sits in exactly the right warm neutral register.
How I’m styling it: with almost everything, as it turns out. It has already appeared in four different outfits this week — over the shoulder with the plaid trousers, clipped to a belt loop with the jeans-and-turtleneck outfit, worn crossbody with the slip dress and leather jacket, and carried by hand with the rust blazer look. A well-proportioned structured crossbody in a warm neutral leather is one of those accessories that earns its place in every single outfit, and at four dollars it is one of the best things I have ever found at a thrift store.
What I Put Back and Why
The things I decided not to buy are just as instructive as the things I did buy, so I want to spend a few minutes on this before I sign off.
I put back a beautiful forest green wool coat because the shoulders were two inches too wide and there was no fixing that without a full shoulder alteration that would have cost more than the coat was worth. The fabric was gorgeous, the colour was perfect, and it killed me a little to hang it back up. But a coat that doesn’t fit in the shoulders doesn’t fit, and no amount of wanting it makes that different.
I put back a pair of brown suede ankle boots that were in almost perfect condition because when I measured the interior they were a full size smaller than the label suggested — a common issue with older footwear — and would not have fit regardless of how much I wanted them to. Knowing your measurements matters more than hoping for the best.
I put back an interesting printed blouse because even though I loved the print, I couldn’t identify a single thing in my current wardrobe that it would work with. It would have been a purchase driven by liking the piece in isolation rather than by knowing how it would live in my wardrobe — exactly the kind of purchase I’ve trained myself out of making over the years.
These decisions — the ones where you put something back because the fit is wrong or the piece doesn’t integrate — are what separate a useful thrift haul from a pile of cheap things that you like in theory but never actually wear. The discipline of putting things back is as important as the skill of finding them in the first place.
The Total and What It Means
Eight pieces. Total spend: thirty-five dollars including tax. I now have a rust corduroy blazer, a cream cable-knit turtleneck, wide-leg plaid trousers, a black midi slip dress, a camel leather belt, a vintage denim jacket, a burgundy midi skirt, and a cognac brown leather crossbody bag. These pieces work together in dozens of combinations — I counted fourteen distinct outfits I can build from just these eight items plus the basics already in my closet — and they fill specific gaps in my wardrobe that I’d identified before walking into the store.
That is what a good thrift haul looks like. Not just cheap things. Not just an accidental collection of random finds. A deliberate, edited group of pieces that were chosen with clear criteria, that work together and with what you already own, and that represent genuine quality at a price that makes sense for how you actually live.
Tell me in the comments about your best recent thrift find — I want to hear what you found and how much you paid because these stories are my favourite things to read.
Until next time, dolls.
xoxo,
Olivia